Cross-Origin-Opener-Policy: same-origin
top of page
Eric J. Mac Donald, PGA Golf Instruction logo

Eric J. Mac Donald, PGA

8574888986

1401 NW 51st Street, Boca Raton, FL

Super Speed Golf Certified Level Golf Instruction
Professional Golfers Association of America Member
FlightScope Professional Certification logo
SAM Certified Putting Instructor Level 3

CERTIFICATIONS

The Stack System Logo
Trackman Golf Level 2 certification
TPI Titleist Performance Institute  logo
PDI Player Development Index certification logo
GolfForever Certification Badge

What Golfers Say

"Things are going really well. The good shots are outnumbering the bad, significantly! The belief in my swing that you discussed has really helped. Thanks so much!" - Stu B

Finding the Right Challenge Point in Golf Practice: A Path to Real Improvement


Finding the right challenge point to improve your golf game
Finding the right challenge point to improve your golf game

When it comes to improving your golf game, finding the right level of challenge in your drills, games, and activities is crucial. This balance, known as the “challenge point,” can dramatically influence how well you learn, adapt, and ultimately perform on the course. In this post, we’ll explore what the challenge point is, why it’s essential for your development, and how to apply it to your practice so you can see genuine improvement.


What is the Challenge Point?


The concept of the challenge point comes from learning theory. It represents the optimal level of difficulty that keeps a task challenging enough to require focus and effort, without becoming overwhelming or too easy. When practice activities are designed at this level, they stimulate learning by engaging your brain and body to adapt, analyze, and refine skills. In golf, the right challenge point allows players to push beyond their comfort zone, encouraging growth while building confidence in their abilities.


Why Finding the Right Challenge Point Matters in Golf


Golf is a sport that demands a blend of skill, strategy, and mental resilience. The challenge point can make all the difference between just going through the motions in practice and genuinely sharpening your game. When you practice at the correct challenge level, you increase your ability to perform under pressure, build consistency, and develop adaptability—all essential for success on the course.


Finding the right challenge point means striking a balance between skill level and task difficulty. For instance, if a drill is too easy, you won’t learn much because it doesn’t force you to stretch your abilities. On the other hand, if it’s too difficult, you may become frustrated, leading to mistakes and potentially bad habits.


How to Apply the Challenge Point in Golf Practice


To use the challenge point effectively, focus on adjusting three key areas: task difficulty, repetition, and variability. Here’s a breakdown of how to incorporate these elements into your practice:


1. Start with the Basics, Then Increase Complexity:

Begin with drills that focus on fundamentals, like swing path or putting stroke. As you feel more comfortable, increase the complexity. For example, if you’re practicing putting, start by putting from a short distance and then move further away, or add obstacles to simulate on-course conditions.


2. Use Variability to Simulate Real Course Conditions:

Consistent practice on the range doesn’t necessarily translate to on-course performance. To bridge this gap, add variability to your drills by changing targets, shot shapes, or yardages. Practicing with variability helps your brain adapt and prepare for the variety you’ll face during an actual round. For instance, instead of hitting the same 7-iron shot repeatedly, try alternating between high and low shots or different directions. This kind of variability helps you stay adaptable and responsive.


3. Gauge Your Success Rate to Adjust Difficulty:

A good rule of thumb for challenge point in learning activities is that you should be successful about 60-80% of the time. If you’re consistently succeeding beyond that range, increase the challenge. This could mean using a smaller target, introducing a mental challenge like “one-shot only,” or adding a competitive element, such as a score goal. If your success rate drops below 60%, reduce the difficulty slightly to prevent frustration while still challenging yourself.


4. Incorporate Pressure Scenarios:

Since golf requires performance under pressure, it’s essential to replicate this in your practice. Try incorporating mini-competitions or “pressure drills” that simulate the intensity of a real match. For example, play a game where you have to make three consecutive putts from different distances. Adding an element of pressure helps your mind and body get used to performing well when stakes are high.


5. Monitor Progress and Adjust Regularly:

The right challenge point isn’t a static concept—it should change as you progress. Be honest with yourself about how each drill feels and whether it’s pushing you to improve without overwhelming you. Track your progress and adjust difficulty as you gain skill, confidence, and consistency.


Examples of Drills with Adjustable Challenge Points


Driving Accuracy Game: Begin by aiming at a larger target area and work your way down to smaller sections. To add challenge, alternate targets with different distances or simulate “fairway” widths of varying sizes.


Three-Level Putting Drill: Start by making three putts from a shorter distance (e.g., 3 feet). Once you make all three, step back to 6 feet, then to 9 feet. Increase the difficulty by putting from greater distances or under pressure to complete the drill within a certain time.


Shot Shaping Practice: For more advanced players, practice hitting draws and fades on command. Start with larger target areas, then narrow them as you become more consistent. You can also add a “penalty” for each shot that doesn’t match your intended shape to simulate on-course consequences.


The Benefits of Practicing at the Right Challenge Point


When you integrate the challenge point into your practice routine, you’ll find yourself more engaged, focused, and motivated. This kind of deliberate, challenging practice helps with:


Enhanced Skill Retention: When your brain has to work through different challenges, it’s more likely to retain the skills you’re working on.


Increased Confidence: When you successfully complete tasks at the right difficulty, you build self-assurance that translates to better performance under pressure.


Improved On-Course Performance: Practicing at the right challenge point prepares you for the dynamic conditions of the course, making you more adaptable and resilient.


Conclusion


Finding and applying the right challenge point in your practice is an effective way to accelerate your growth as a golfer. By designing drills that strike a balance between comfort and difficulty, you’ll build skills that stand up to real course conditions. Remember, the journey to improvement isn’t about taking the easiest path—it’s about finding that sweet spot of challenging practice that drives real progress.


At www.ericjmacdonaldpga.com, I’m here to help you find the right approach to your training so that every session counts. Let’s work together to design a practice routine that not only fits your skill level but also inspires you to reach new heights in your golf game.

Comments


Eric J. Mac Donald, PGA Southeast Chapter South Florida PGA Assistant Professional of the Year Award 2023

About Me

With over a decade of experience and certifications in TPI, TrackMan, and SAM PuttLab, plus an MBA from Boston University, I specialize in helping golfers add distance, control their short game, and improve their mental toughness. Named 2023 Assistant Professional of the Year by the South Florida PGA, my goal is to equip you with tools and confidence—not just hits.

Read More About Eric J. Mac Donald

 

  • Youtube
  • Instagram
  • X
  • Facebook

© 2023 by Eric J. Mac Donald, PGA

bottom of page